Defining Art
This topic investigates the criteria used to define art and the role of the artist's intention. Students analyze controversial works to test the boundaries of what constitutes art.
TL;DR:Defining art is one of the most challenging tasks in aesthetics. Students investigate the criteria used to distinguish 'art' from 'non-art,' including the role of the artist's intention, the institutional theory of art, and the importance of context. This topic aligns with the Ontario curriculum's focus on analyzing different philosophical definitions of art.
About This Topic
Defining art is one of the most challenging tasks in aesthetics. Students investigate the criteria used to distinguish 'art' from 'non-art,' including the role of the artist's intention, the institutional theory of art, and the importance of context. This topic aligns with the Ontario curriculum's focus on analyzing different philosophical definitions of art.
In a Canadian context, this might involve looking at controversial public art or the distinction between 'craft' and 'fine art' in Indigenous traditions. Students learn to test the boundaries of these definitions by examining 'edge cases' like found objects or AI-generated images. This topic is most effective when students engage in collaborative investigations and 'curate' their own exhibitions based on specific philosophical definitions.
Key Questions
- What is art?
- Does art need to have a purpose or meaning?
- How does context change our understanding of an artwork?
Watch Out for These Misconceptions
Common MisconceptionArt has to be 'good' to be art.
What to Teach Instead
Something can be 'bad art' but still be art. Active learning that separates 'classification' (is it art?) from 'evaluation' (is it good?) helps students understand the philosophical task of defining art.
Common MisconceptionIf I can do it, it's not art.
What to Teach Instead
This ignores the role of the *idea* or the *context* in modern art. Peer-led discussions about conceptual art can help students see that 'art' is often about the question it asks, not just the skill it took to make.
Active Learning Ideas
See all activities→Inquiry Circle
The 'Is It Art?' Museum
Provide groups with images of controversial works (e.g., Duchamp's Fountain, a child's drawing, a sunset). They must use three different philosophical definitions of art to argue why each one is or is not art.
Role Play
The Grant Committee
Students act as a government committee deciding which 'art' projects to fund. They must create a set of criteria for what counts as 'art' and defend it against 'artists' (other students) who are pushing the boundaries.
Think-Pair-Share
The Artist's Intention
Show a work of art that was created by accident (e.g., a spill). Students discuss in pairs: 'Does the lack of intention mean it's not art?' and 'Does it matter if the viewer *thinks* it was intentional?'
Frequently Asked Questions
How can active learning help students understand the definition of art?
How do I handle AI-generated art in this unit?
Why is the 'Institutional Theory of Art' important?
How can I include Indigenous perspectives on defining art?
More in Aesthetics and the Philosophy of Art
The Nature of Beauty
Students explore the philosophical definition of beauty and whether it is an objective property or a subjective experience. They examine how aesthetic judgments are formed.
8 methodologies
Art, Morality, and Society
Students examine the relationship between art, ethics, and society, including issues of censorship and the social responsibility of artists. They debate whether art should be judged on moral grounds.
8 methodologies