The Numbered Treaties: Context and Motivations
Comparing the written text of treaties with the oral traditions and understandings of First Nations.
Key Questions
- Explain why First Nations leaders entered into treaty negotiations during the late 19th century.
- Analyze the motivations of the Canadian government in pursuing the Numbered Treaties.
- Differentiate the perspectives of First Nations and the Crown regarding treaty objectives.
Ontario Curriculum Expectations
About This Topic
The Residential School System is a painful but essential part of Canadian history. Students examine the origins and early operation of these schools, which were designed with the explicit goal to 'kill the Indian in the child.' This topic focuses on the partnership between the federal government and Christian churches and the devastating impact of separating children from their families, languages, and cultures.
Students will investigate the Davos-Scott report of 1907, which highlighted the appalling health conditions and high death rates in the schools, and the government's failure to act. This topic requires a trauma-informed and sensitive approach, focusing on the resilience of survivors and the ongoing process of Truth and Reconciliation. This topic comes alive when students can use primary source evidence and survivor testimony to understand the systemic nature of the schools and the long-term impacts on Indigenous communities.
Active Learning Ideas
Inquiry Circle: The Davos-Scott Report
In small groups, students read excerpts from Dr. Peter Bryce's (Davos-Scott) 1907 report on health in residential schools. They identify the specific problems he found and discuss why the government chose to ignore his recommendations.
Think-Pair-Share: The Power of Language
Students reflect on what it would feel like to be forbidden from speaking their own language. They pair up to discuss how the loss of language affects a person's connection to their family and culture over generations.
Gallery Walk: Resilience and Survival
Display stories and artwork by residential school survivors that highlight their strength and the ways they maintained their identity. Students use a 'reflection journal' to record their thoughts and questions.
Watch Out for These Misconceptions
Common MisconceptionResidential schools were just like regular boarding schools.
What to Teach Instead
Unlike regular boarding schools, attendance was often mandatory, and the primary goal was to eliminate the students' culture and identity. Using a 'comparison chart' of goals and methods helps students see the unique and harmful nature of the residential school system.
Common MisconceptionThe government didn't know how bad the conditions were.
What to Teach Instead
Reports like the Davos-Scott report proved that the government was fully aware of the high death rates and poor conditions but chose not to provide the necessary funding to fix them. Analyzing these reports helps students understand the systemic neglect involved.
Suggested Methodologies
Ready to teach this topic?
Generate a complete, classroom-ready active learning mission in seconds.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the purpose of residential schools?
How many children attended residential schools?
What is the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC)?
How can active learning help students understand the residential school system?
More in Indigenous Realities and Resistance
The Indian Act of 1876: Origins and Goals
Deconstructing the legislation that gave the federal government control over First Nations lives and identity.
3 methodologies
The Indian Act: Impacts on Identity and Governance
Students examine how the Indian Act defined 'Status' and restricted traditional Indigenous governance and ceremonies.
3 methodologies
The Numbered Treaties: Spirit and Intent
Students investigate the concept of 'Spirit and Intent' versus the literal legal text of the Numbered Treaties.
3 methodologies
Residential Schools: Origins and Early Operation
Examining the origins and early operation of schools designed to 'kill the Indian in the child.'
3 methodologies
Residential Schools: Impacts and Resistance
Students investigate the long-term impacts of residential schools and early forms of Indigenous resistance to the system.
3 methodologies