The Art of the Critique: Giving Feedback
Learning to provide constructive feedback using specific artistic vocabulary and objective criteria.
Key Questions
- Explain the most effective way to suggest improvements without discouraging the artist.
- Differentiate between personal preference and objective artistic quality in a critique.
- Construct a verbal critique that uses specific artistic vocabulary.
Ontario Curriculum Expectations
About This Topic
Watersheds and Water Quality introduces students to the concept that everyone lives 'downstream' from someone else. They study how water moves through the landscape, from high points to low points, forming watersheds. In Ontario, this is vital as we are stewards of the Great Lakes, which hold 20% of the world's fresh surface water. Students learn how land use, such as farming, industry, and urban development, affects the health of these water systems.
This topic emphasizes the importance of wetlands as natural filters and the role of Conservation Authorities in Ontario. Students also learn about Indigenous perspectives on water as a sacred living entity and the role of 'Water Walkers' like Josephine Mandamin. This topic comes alive when students can model a watershed and observe how pollutants spread through a system in real-time.
Active Learning Ideas
Inquiry Circle: Crumpled Paper Watershed
Students crumple a large sheet of paper, then slightly uncrumple it to create 'mountains' and 'valleys.' They use markers to draw 'pollution' on the peaks and spray water to see where the 'runoff' collects.
Stations Rotation: Water Quality Testing
Students test different water samples (tap, pond, 'simulated' runoff) for pH, turbidity, and temperature. They must determine which sample is healthiest for local fish species.
Think-Pair-Share: The Sacred Water
Students read about the Indigenous-led Water Walks around the Great Lakes. They discuss in pairs how viewing water as a 'relative' rather than a 'resource' might change how we treat our local rivers.
Watch Out for These Misconceptions
Common MisconceptionWater pollution only comes from big factories (point source).
What to Teach Instead
Explain that most pollution today is 'non-point source,' like oil from driveways or fertilizer from lawns. The 'Crumpled Paper' activity is excellent for showing how small amounts of waste from many locations combine into a major problem.
Common MisconceptionA watershed is only the water (rivers and lakes) itself.
What to Teach Instead
Clarify that a watershed includes all the land that drains into a body of water. Using a topographic map of their local area helps students see that their own backyard is part of a larger watershed system.
Suggested Methodologies
Ready to teach this topic?
Generate a complete, classroom-ready active learning mission in seconds.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a watershed?
How can active learning help students understand water quality?
Why are wetlands important for water quality?
What are the main threats to Ontario's water?
More in The Critic's Eye: Analysis and Curation
The Art of the Critique: Receiving Feedback
Students practice actively listening to and interpreting feedback on their own work, and using it for revision.
3 methodologies
Curating an Exhibition: Selection and Theme
Students act as curators, selecting works and organizing them to tell a specific story or explore a theme.
3 methodologies
Curating an Exhibition: Arrangement and Interpretation
Students explore how the arrangement of objects and accompanying text influence the viewer's journey and interaction with art.
3 methodologies
Art and Social Change: Activism
Exploring how contemporary artists use their work as a tool for social activism to address environmental, political, and social issues.
3 methodologies
Art and Social Change: Cultural Identity
Students investigate how artists use their work to explore and affirm cultural identity, heritage, and personal narratives.
3 methodologies