Classification of law provides the organisational framework students need to navigate the legal landscape. This topic distinguishes between public law, which governs the relationship between individuals and the state (criminal, administrative, and constitutional law), and private law, which deals with disputes between individuals or organisations (contract, tort, and property law). Students also compare the procedural differences between criminal and civil jurisdictions.
ACARA Content DescriptionsNESA Preliminary Outcome P1NESA Preliminary Outcome P5
Post various legal scenarios around the room (e.g., a breach of contract, a robbery, a dispute over a fence). Students move in pairs to categorise each as public or private law, noting the likely parties involved and the standard of proof required.
What is the difference between public and private law?
Run two mini-trials for the same event (e.g., a car accident). One trial focuses on the criminal charge of reckless driving (beyond reasonable doubt), while the other focuses on the civil claim for damages (balance of probabilities).
How do criminal and civil court procedures differ?
Each student is assigned a role (Solicitor, Barrister, Magistrate, Judge, Tipstaff). They must create a 'job profile' and then rotate through groups to explain their responsibilities and where they sit in the court hierarchy.
Juries are actually quite rare, used primarily in serious criminal matters in higher courts and occasionally in civil defamation cases. Most matters are heard by a Magistrate or Judge alone. A 'court hierarchy' flow chart helps students see where juries actually sit.
If you lose a civil case, you go to jail.
Civil law aims to provide a remedy (usually money) to the person wronged, not to punish the offender with imprisonment. Imprisonment is a sanction reserved for criminal law. Role playing the 'sentencing' vs 'remedy' phase clarifies this distinction.