Global Challenges and Future Horizons · Semester 2

Global City vs. Nation State: Immigration and Identity

Students explore the tension between remaining open to the world as a global city and addressing the concerns of local citizens.

About This Topic

Singapore faces a constant tension between being a 'Global City' that is open to the world and being a 'Nation State' that must protect the interests of its citizens. This topic explores the challenges of immigration, the rising cost of living in a global hub, and the need to maintain a 'Singaporean core' in the workforce. It looks at how the government balances the need for global talent with the concerns of locals over jobs and identity.

This topic is a study in 'globalisation and its discontents.' It connects to the MOE syllabus by examining 'national identity' and 'economic survival.' Students benefit from active learning by 'debating' the pros and cons of an open-door policy for a small nation.

Active Learning Ideas

Formal Debate: The Global Hub Dilemma

Students debate: 'Should Singapore limit the number of foreign workers even if it slows down the economy?' They must consider the impact on local businesses and the cost of living versus the concerns of citizens over job competition and social identity.

⏱ 45 min·Whole Class

Generate mission

Inquiry Circle: The Singaporean Core

Groups research one government policy aimed at protecting local workers (e.g., the Fair Consideration Framework or the COMPASS system for EP holders). They must present how this policy helps maintain a 'Singaporean core' in the workforce.

⏱ 40 min·Small Groups

Generate mission

Think-Pair-Share: What Makes a 'Local'?

Students discuss: 'Can someone who wasn't born here ever be truly 'Singaporean'?' They pair up to list the 'qualities' that define a Singaporean (e.g., values, language, contribution) and share their views with the class.

⏱ 20 min·Pairs

Generate mission

Watch Out for These Misconceptions

Common Misconception

Immigrants are the only reason why the cost of living is high.

What to Teach Instead

The cost of living is also driven by global factors like inflation, energy prices, and Singapore's status as a high-income financial hub. A 'cost driver' pie chart activity can help students see the variety of factors that affect their daily expenses.

Common Misconception

Singapore can survive without any foreign workers.

What to Teach Instead

With a shrinking local workforce, foreign workers are essential for many sectors, from construction to high-tech research. A 'workforce gap' analysis can help students see the 'holes' that would appear in the economy if all foreign workers left.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Singapore be both a global hub and a cohesive nation?

This is the central challenge for Singapore. While being a global hub brings wealth and opportunities, it also brings rapid change and competition. The government tries to manage this by investing in local skills, ensuring fair hiring practices, and promoting social integration to keep the nation cohesive.

How does immigration affect the 'Singaporean core'?

Immigration helps to supplement the local workforce and offset the low birth rate. However, if not managed carefully, it can lead to concerns about job competition and the dilution of local culture. The government uses a quota system and strict criteria to ensure that immigrants contribute to, rather than replace, the 'Singaporean core.'

How can active learning help students understand globalization?

By debating the 'Global Hub' dilemma, students realize that there are no easy solutions. They learn that every choice has a trade-off, for example, fewer foreign workers might mean higher wages for some, but also higher prices for everyone. This helps them appreciate the complexity of managing a modern city-state.

What are the challenges of rising cost of living in a global city?

In a global city, prices for housing, transport, and services are often driven by international demand. This can make it difficult for local citizens, especially those with lower incomes, to keep up. The government uses targeted subsidies (like U-Save and GST Vouchers) to help locals manage these costs.

Browse curriculum by country

• Americas
• US
• CA
• MX
• CL
• CO
• BR

• Europe
• UK
• IE
• FR
• DE
• ES
• IT
• NL
• PT
• SE

• Asia & Pacific
• IN
• SG
• AU