The Tudor Dynasty: Power and Religion · Autumn Term

Poverty and the Poor Laws

How the Elizabethans categorised and dealt with the growing problem of the 'wandering poor'.

About This Topic

Poverty and the Poor Laws topic explores how Elizabethan England faced growing social challenges from population increase, enclosures, and vagrancy. Students differentiate the 'deserving poor,' such as the elderly, infirm, and fatherless children who received parish relief, from the 'undeserving poor,' like able-bodied wanderers punished by whipping or stocks. This distinction reveals Tudor attitudes to welfare and order.

The 1601 Poor Law stands as a turning point, requiring parishes to appoint overseers for weekly collections, provide work for the able-bodied, and apprentice poor children. Students analyze its causes, including rapid population growth straining resources, and its impact on local communities. This aligns with KS3 standards in social and cultural history, building skills in causation, change, and empathy.

Active learning suits this topic well. Role-plays of overseer meetings or debates on categorizing beggars let students apply historical criteria to scenarios, fostering critical thinking. Group source analysis turns policies into vivid stories, making the human cost of poverty tangible and aiding retention of complex ideas.

Learning Objectives

• Classify individuals in Elizabethan society as either 'deserving' or 'undeserving' poor based on provided case studies.
• Analyze the social, economic, and demographic factors that contributed to increased poverty in Elizabethan England.
• Explain the key provisions of the 1601 Poor Law and evaluate its significance as a turning point in social welfare history.
• Compare and contrast the methods used to deal with poverty before and after the 1601 Poor Law.

Before You Start

Life in Tudor England

Why: Students need a foundational understanding of Elizabethan society, including its social structure and daily life, to grasp the context of poverty and its causes.

The English Reformation

Why: Understanding the dissolution of the monasteries is crucial, as this removed a traditional source of charity and relief for the poor, contributing to the problem the Poor Laws aimed to address.

Key Vocabulary

Vagrancy	The condition of wandering from place to place without a settled home or visible means of support, often associated with poverty and perceived idleness.
Parish Relief	Support provided to the poor by the local church parish, typically funded by collections and overseen by churchwardens or later, poor law officials.
Able-bodied Poor	Individuals considered capable of working but who were unemployed, often viewed with suspicion and subject to harsher treatment under poor laws.
Overseers of the Poor	Parish officials appointed under the 1601 Poor Law responsible for collecting funds and administering relief to the poor within their parish.
Apprenticeship	A system where children from poor families were bound to a master craftsman or farmer for a set number of years to learn a trade or skill.

Active Learning Ideas

Role-Play: Overseer Decisions

Assign roles as parish overseers, deserving poor, and vagrants. Groups review case files based on 1601 laws, vote on aid or punishment, then justify choices to the class. Debrief connects decisions to historical context.

⏱ 45 min·Small Groups

Generate mission

Source Stations: Categorizing Poverty

Set up stations with images, extracts, and accounts of poor types. Small groups rotate, sort evidence into deserving/undeserving categories, and note population pressures. Each group presents one key finding.

⏱ 40 min·Small Groups

Generate mission

Formal Debate: Poor Law Effectiveness

Divide class into teams to argue if the 1601 law solved or worsened poverty. Provide sources on successes and failures. Vote and reflect on evidence use.

⏱ 35 min·Whole Class

Generate mission

Timeline Build: Causes to Reforms

In pairs, students sequence cards on population growth, vagrancy acts, and Poor Laws. Add impacts and present timelines, explaining turning points.

⏱ 30 min·Pairs

Generate mission

Real-World Connections

Modern social workers and charities, like the Trussell Trust food banks, continue to categorize individuals needing assistance, distinguishing between those facing temporary hardship and those with long-term needs, echoing Elizabethan distinctions.

Local government councils today administer welfare benefits and social care services, a direct descendant of the parish-based system established by the 1601 Poor Law, aiming to support vulnerable citizens.

Watch Out for These Misconceptions

Common Misconception

All poor people were lazy vagrants.

What to Teach Instead

Many were victims of circumstance, like harvest failures or illness. Role-plays help students apply deserving/undeserving criteria to cases, revealing nuance and challenging stereotypes through peer discussion.

Common Misconception

The 1601 Poor Law ended poverty completely.

What to Teach Instead

It provided local relief but did not address root causes like enclosures. Debates on its limits encourage source evaluation, showing students how historians assess short-term vs long-term change.

Common Misconception

Population growth had no role in poverty.

What to Teach Instead

Rapid growth outpaced food and jobs, swelling vagrancy. Mapping activities link demographics to policies, helping students see causation via visual evidence.

Assessment Ideas

Discussion Prompt

Pose the question: 'Imagine you are a parish overseer in 1590. A man with no visible injury asks for food, claiming he cannot find work. How would you categorize him, and what action would you take? Justify your decision using Elizabethan attitudes.' Facilitate a class debate on differing opinions.

Quick Check

Provide students with short biographical sketches of four individuals from Elizabethan times. Ask them to write down whether each person would be considered 'deserving' or 'undeserving' poor and briefly explain why, referencing specific details from the sketch.

Exit Ticket

On a slip of paper, ask students to write one sentence explaining why the 1601 Poor Law was a 'turning point' and one sentence describing a specific challenge faced by the Elizabethan poor that led to this law.

Frequently Asked Questions

How did Elizabethans distinguish deserving from undeserving poor?

Deserving poor included the impotent like elderly or disabled, who got relief; undeserving were sturdy beggars, punished to deter idleness. Students use tables to classify sources, building analytical skills for KS3 history.

Why was the 1601 Poor Law a turning point?

It created a national, parish-funded system for relief, workhouses, and apprenticeships, shifting from ad-hoc charity. Analysis of pre- and post-law sources shows centralized responsibility, a model until 1948.

What caused poverty in Elizabethan England?

Population doubled to 4 million, enclosures reduced common land, inflation hit wages, and trade disruptions added unemployment. Graphs and accounts help students connect economic factors to vagrancy laws.

How can active learning teach Poverty and the Poor Laws?

Role-plays and debates immerse students in overseer dilemmas, making categories memorable. Source stations build evidence skills collaboratively. These methods develop empathy and causation analysis, key for KS3, while keeping lessons engaging over lectures.