Activity 01
Structured Academic Controversy: Who Decides the Amazon's Future?
Assign groups one of four stakeholder positions: Brazilian government official, indigenous community leader, international environmental NGO, or commercial rancher. Groups read a one-page brief and engage in structured dialogue where each position must be accurately summarized by opponents before the debate continues. The class works toward a synthesized policy statement.
Analyze the global impact of the Amazon Rainforest on climate and biodiversity.
Facilitation TipDuring Structured Academic Controversy: Who Decides the Amazon's Future?, assign clear roles (e.g., indigenous leader, cattle rancher, global consumer) and require students to cite data from the Collaborative Data Analysis activity in their arguments.
What to look forPose the following question to small groups: 'Imagine you are advising a government official in an Amazonian country. Present arguments for prioritizing either economic development (e.g., logging, farming) or rainforest conservation. Be prepared to defend your position using evidence about climate, biodiversity, and livelihoods.'